View more on these topics

Proc fee levels do not sway brokers’ choice of lender: FCA

FCA logo new 3 620x430

The FCA says it does not believe that variations in the level of procuration fee paid by different lenders lead to bias among brokers or poor outcomes for borrowers.

The watchdog reached this conclusion in its interim report into mortgage competition today, which drew upon analysis of 2016 home loans sales.

The figures exclude the wave of retention proc fees from mainstream lenders that emerged through 2017.

However, the FCA says it does not think the widespread and sudden payment of retention proc fees by many lenders has biased brokers.

Speaking to Mortgage Strategy, FCA director of competition and economics Deb Jones says: “The question we asked of ourselves was: are proc fees influencing business?

“We investigated and found no significant influence on consumer outcomes.

“What we were really looking at was, where there is a difference in the level of fees, did more business go to that lender via fees?

“The analysis showed no evidence of bias.”

In today’s report, the FCA revealed that the median level of proc fee paid is around 0.4 per cent of the loan amount.

Based on the typical mortgage size of £147,000, it says that proc fee differentials could lead to a broker earning £120 more by referring a case to the lender that pays the highest commission.

But it says: “While we recognise that there is potential for procuration fee bias where intermediaries face products with large differences in procuration fees across lenders, we find little evidence that intermediaries selling more costly mortgages is linked to high procuration fees.”



FCA fleshes out broker comparison tool plans

The Financial Conduct Authority has given more details of its plans to set up a service that lets consumers compare mortgage brokers. The plans were unveiled this morning in the regulator’s interim mortgage competition report. Speaking to Mortgage Strategy, FCA director of competition and economics Deb Jones says the watchdog’s research has shown that the broker […]


Industry responds to FCA interim mortgage market study

  Today the FCA published its interim report into mortgage market competition, first mooted in 2015. The Financial Conduct Authority has singled out mortgage prisoners, shopping around and a broker comparison service as areas of the market that need change. The news sparked a wave of responses from the industry. UK Finance director of mortgages […]


FCA: New focus on shopping around will not dilute MMR 

  A new Financial Conduct Authority focus on helping consumers shop around will not dilute the requirements brought in by the Mortgage Market Review, according to the regulator’s competition chief.  The FCA today brought out its interim report into mortgage market competition, which says there is no easy way for consumers to know which mortgages they qualify for at an early stage, hindering shopping around.  The regulator […]

In Focus Ebola cover - thumbnail

White paper — In Focus: Ebola Virus Disease

Jelf Employee Benefits focuses on Ebola Virus Disease (EVD) and what this means for businesses with operations in West Africa. This will be of particular interest to those with employees either travelling to, or living within, West Africa, the area affected by the most catastrophic outbreak of Ebola to date.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up