View more on these topics

News analysis: Do lenders pay brokers enough for retention?

A significant numbers of lenders have finally recognised the value of retention business but fees often remain much lower than they do for new business


Lenders are failing to pay high enough fees for retention business, advisers say, as their hopes of achieving payments on a par with, or largely close to, those for new business are unfulfilled.

While just two of the major lenders are yet to introduce procuration payments on retention business, advisers say the compensation being offered is not enough. A drive to support intermediaries helping customers switch product at the end of their mortgage deal has seen many major providers introduce retention proc fees.

RBS and Natwest are among the only major providers yet to implement the new payments, a Mortgage Strategy investigation can reveal. These fees are paid to advisers who transfer existing customers to new deals with the same lender once their mortgage term matures.

Lloyds Banking Group says it first introduced proc fees for product transfers 11 years ago. The bank, which pays a full proc fee for retention business, says: “We set out to ensure that broker’s advice between a product transfer and a remortgage option could not be influenced by fee considerations.”

The fees for both are the same, at 0.35 per cent.

Chadney Bulgin mortgage partner Jonathan Clark says: “When Halifax started paying out a full fee we thought other lenders would follow and they didn’t. It has not got to the point where more lenders are paying fees than aren’t. Those which aren’t doing it yet say they soon will.”

But Clark says the problem is that at many providers the fees for retention business are much lower than those paid for new business. The difference between the two can frequently be 10 basis points or more.

He says: “I don’t think we should get the same rate as we do for new business, but it should be higher than it is as we have to do a similar amount of work for each. I think most brokers would argue it’s not enough at the moment.”

There is also a wide disparity between the level of fees paid by providers. While Lloyds’ pays a generous fee, others pay just half that.

OneSavings Bank introduced a 0.25 per cent retention procuration fee in June last year and says it keeps the fee under constant review.

Virgin Money brought in the fees a month later, in July 2016, paying 0.38 per cent. The bank says it wants to support its intermediary partners to grow their businesses.

Brokers are paid a proc fee for returning an existing mortgage customer to the bank upon maturity of their existing product.

Santander started payments this year, introducing them for networks and mortgage clubs in March and rolling them out across the business through to July. The bank now pays 0.2 per cent on all retention business transacted through its online portal.

Aldermore brought the fees into effect in April, offering a net payment of 0.3 per cent. It is available on residential owner-occupied and standard BTL loans. The challenger bank says the move was ‘part of its ongoing commitment to its broker partnerships’.

Accord, the intermediary arm of Yorkshire Building Society, introduced proc fees on retention business in July. The lender pays a gross fee of 0.3 per cent on residential mortgage products. It doesn’t pay retention fees on BTL mortgages but says it aims to offer this by the end of the year.

Nationwide and its BTL arm, The Mortgage Works, introduced retention proc fees in August. The provider pays a gross fee of 0.2 per cent to intermediaries switching existing customers to new products.

Middleton Finance director Daniel Bailey says: “While it’s positive many lenders have introduced fees, they should be higher. The onus is on us to do all of the compliance and due diligence and the lender gets presented with a client that they get to keep for another two or five years. Yet in many cases we only get half the fee.

“Proc fees in general haven’t increased in a lot of years and, at the same time, because of regulation and compliance changes, our costs have increased significantly.”

Lagging the pack are RBS and Natwest, which have not yet introduced procuration fees for retention business. The bank says it is looking to introduce the payments by the end of the year but no date has yet been set. When introduced, the fee is likely to be 0.2 per cent on both residential and BTL business, the lenders say.



Barclays introduces proc fee for further advances

 Barclays Mortgages is introducing a procuration payment of 0.3 per cent on all new residential and buy-to-let further advance cases. The lender says it recognises the efforts made by brokers on advising and completing these cases. It says applications submitted from Friday 22nd September onwards will be eligible for the new payment. Barclays director of […]


Nationwide to pay retention proc fees from today

Nationwide has confirmed it will pay mortgage brokers retention procuration fees for all prime mortgage applications from today. The lender will pay 0.20 per cent to all brokers, with no phased roll-out. Mortgage Strategy previously reported that the lender was set to make the payments at the end of August or beginning of September, but […]


Keystone brings forward proc fee rise

Keystone Property Finance is bringing forward its planned procuration fee rise by one month.  Brokers will get an extra 10 basis points from 1 September when completing the lender’s classic range cases. The lender currently pays 0.6 per cent to directly-authorised brokers, though some network brokers get slightly more. A Keystone statement says: “The new […]

Auto enrolment – so far so good?

Jamie Clark – Business Development Manager The recent report from the Pensions Policy Institute demonstrates the sheer scale of auto-enrolment so far and what we can expect in the future. We’ve pulled out the key information to save you reading the full report. Auto enrolment in numbers Sources: Pensions Policy Institute, The Future Book: Unravelling […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up