View more on these topics

Network Review: Embroidery of AR numbers

A quarterly round-up of appointed representative networks  


Brokers are telling us that, in the main, the second quarter was a good one, with the housing market continuing to rise along with the number of mortgages. 

Remortgages still faced problems, with affordability (or lack of it) continuing to block many potential borrowers. This is unlikely to radically improve in the near future so we will just have to wait until it sorts itself out.

In terms of recruitment, other than changes caused through major acquisitions or problems, movement within the sector was fairly subdued. This is typical when business is good. 

To illustrate this, Q2 saw 195 authorised representatives join a network, whereas the same period of the dark days of 2010 saw 645 (see table below). And this is not just symptomatic of a shrinking industry. In the same timespan, 172 ARs left networks this year, compared to 718 doing so back in 2010.

A major issue in Q2, however, was some huge exaggerations of business-writing AR numbers. To spare blushes I will not mention any names but here are a couple of examples: one network said it had more than 100 ARs when the FCA register clearly showed just seven, while another trumpeted the fact it had over 1,000 ARs when the FCA register actually showed under 500. 

Nothing wrong with a bit of salesmanship, you may think, but I believe there is a dark side to this. “Pull the wool over their eyes” and “What they don’t know won’t hurt them” spring to mind.

Drilling down to the numbers now, Intrinsic gets number one spot again with an overall increase of 39 ARs. This was at least partially fuelled by its status as one of Sesame’s preferred exit options, which meant Sesame would pay any professional indemnity excess for moving to the network. 

In second place was First Complete, doing well with an increase of 13 ARs. Meanwhile, Stonebridge took third place numerically with an increase of nine ARs, or first in percentage terms, showing growth in its AR base of 5 per cent.




Brokers confident they can maintain market dominance

Brokers are confident they can maintain their dominance in the mortgage market over the next year, according to a new Mortgage Strategy poll. Last month, we reported that brokers had a market share of 69 per cent in the second quarter – 30 basis points off the previous high in Q1 2008. Brokers have become […]


Average house price up 5.7% to £277k

The average UK house price rose by 5.7 per cent to £277,000 in the year to June, according to the Office for National Statistics. On a monthly basis, prices were up 0.4 per cent from May. Northern Ireland experienced the largest growth over the year, at 9 per cent, followed by England at 6.1 per […]

Finance is only one hurdle for small developers

The housebuilding market in its current form simply isn’t working. We are completely over-reliant on the biggest players in the industry – the largest nine are responsible for more than 50 per cent of the new homes built in the UK. But there is a reluctance to do more, particularly in this uncertain post-Brexit world. And with […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up
  • Post a comment
  • Amir Kharkowa 27th August 2015 at 5:57 am

    Gary needs to go his local greengrocers !

  • We're all doomed!!!!! 26th August 2015 at 3:37 pm

    Some misleading comments here, Gary.

    Firstly, the data comes from the FCA register – Most Networks tend not to disclose this type of information. So, Gary is only able to report on AR numbers. An AR is a firm, not a business writer.

    Therefore, for clarity, the first column in his table should read “A R Firms”, or just “ARs”, rather than Adviser ARs.

    Secondly, Gary talks about exaggerations from Networks – well, maybe the Networks who quoted “more than 100 ARs when the FCA register clearly showed just seven”, while another trumpeted the fact it had over 1,000 ARs when the FCA register actually showed under 500” were talking about business writers, rather than firms.

    The morale of this tale, Gary and the Networks quoted, is to compare apples with apples, not pears!