View more on these topics

Landlords win legal battle over West Brom rate rise


West Bromwich Building Society has lost an Appeal Court battle over whether it was right to raise interest rates on tracker mortgages without a rise in Bank of England base rate.

The case sets a precedent over how the wider mortgage market can treat interest rates.

Handing down the judgment today, Lord Justice Hamblen ruled that interest rates on tracker mortgages should only rise with Bank of England base rate, and West Brom cannot require a landlord to repay the mortgage with one month’s notice.

West Bromwich said that clause five of its mortgage conditions document let it raise its interest rates without a base rate rise.

But Hamblen said that West Bromwich’s offer document for the affected mortgages specifically pegged the interest rate was pegged to base rate.

He says: “The lender was thereby promising that the interest rate would be varied in accordance with and so as to reflect changes in that base rate.”

Hamblen also says that borrowers would be hit hard if West Bromwich called in mortgages with one month’s notice.

He says: “For the lender to have the right to require repayment on one month’s notice at will would give him the right to turn the borrower’s contemplated business arrangements on their head.

“In many, if not most, cases the borrower would be required to terminate the letting arrangements and sell the property in order to make the repayment.

“A property which was to be bought so it could be let could, at the lender’s whim, be required to be unlet and sold.

“Buy-to-let becomes sell unlet.”

Lord Justice Leveson and Lady Justice Sharp agreed with Hamblen’s decisions.

The case began when landlord group Property 118 questioned a decision by West Brom to increase its tracker rate in September 2013 without a base rate rise.

At the time the lender told 6,700 landlords it would increase rates from 1.49 per cent to 3.49 per cent from 1 December 2013. The borrowers all had loans with West Bromwich Mortgage Company, its now defunct specialist lending arm.

The rise meant some landlords saw the interest rate on their mortgages double.

Property 118 launched legal action against West Brom in the High Court in November 2013.

Separately, angry landlords took their cases to the Financial Ombudsman Service. However the FOS threw the cases out in November 2014, saying the lender was allowed to raise its rates.

Judge Nigel Teare of the High Court then sided with West Brom in January 2015, saying the lender was allowed to increase its rates to handle changing market conditions.

Teare threw Property 118’s case out, which led to the Property 118 appeal.



Landlords take on West Brom over tracker rate future

The future of tracker mortgages hangs in the balance pending the outcome of the long-running court case involving landlords challenging rate hikes by West Bromwich Building Society. Whichever side wins, there will be a legal precedent set which will affect whether lenders can raise their interest rates without a rise in Bank of England base […]

west brom

Date set for West Brom rate hike appeal

Landlords fighting a West Bromwich Building Society rate hike will take their case to the Court of Appeal on 27 April. A group of landlords are suing the society because of its decision to increase its tracker rate mortgages in September 2013. At the time the lender told 6,700 landlords that it would increase rates […]


Landlords step up legal challenge over buy-to-let tax

Buy-to-let investors are looking to raise a further £250,000 in their bid to fight the cuts to mortgage interest relief set to be phased in from next year. The Telegraph reports campaigners plan a summit in central London to add to the £50,000 already raised as part of plans to launch a judicial review against […]

The Perils of Passive Investing

The era of loose monetary policy created an environment that rewarded passive investors in the US. However, with the US raising interest rates for the first time since 2006, Felix Wintle explains why he believes active investing will be more important than ever. In the video Felix discusses: The rising cost of capital and its […]

A funny old year

The past 12 months have been turbulent – just take a look at this chart of the FTSE 100 over the last year. There have been some points which I’m sure would have caused your clients some concern, and possibly even had them looking for an alternative investment with reduced volatility; perhaps without reducing their […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up
  • Post a comment
  • Samantha Cox 8th June 2016 at 10:56 am

    Does this mean Halifax will review its SVR ‘base rate tracker hike’ from back in 2009? That was pretty eyebrow raising as well!


Why register with Mortgage Strategy?

Mortgage Strategy continues to be the market-leading B2B mortgage publication in the UK, and provides trusted, independent insight with the aim of helping, promoting and analysing the latest developments for mortgage professionals.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Mortgage Strategy Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, webinars and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Mortgage Strategy's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now