View more on these topics

ASA upholds advert complaint against claims firm

The Advertising Standards Authority has upheld a complaint against a claims firm called Unfair Credit Direct which claimed that credit agreements may be unenforceable with an advert headlined ’Mis-sold Mortgages.’

The text in the national press advert read: “”Your unsecured loan & credit card agreements may be unenforceable? Call us now to find out! Do you know that through brand new legislation 70% of credit agreements may be unenforceable?”

A complaint was lodged on the basis that the above statement was misleading, and challenging whether the claim could be backed up.

The ASA also challenged whether the advert should have made clear there was a fee for using the advertiser’s services.

In response Unfair Credit Direct said they had used the advert for two years and had worked with the Ministry of Justice to ensure it was satisfied with the advert.

The firm said that the claim that “70% of credit agreement may be unenforceable” was based on their own industry research, and that it had used the word “may” to allow for the fact the figure may not be correct.

But Unfair Direct also told the ASA that given the legal uncertainty around claims test cases, the company had decided to withdraw the service and would not be offering it again.

The company said it did not charge upfront fees but charged fees once they could progress in contesting a client’s agreement.

It argues that fees were made affordable by monthly payment arrangements, and the company’s terms and conditions made clear that refunds were paid for unsuccessful cases.

In its ruling the ASA says: “The ASA noted that Unfair Credit Direct believed that the word “may” made clear that the 70% figure was conditional.

“However, we did not consider that that alone was sufficient to counter the overall impression created by the ad that, because a large proportion of credit agreements might not be enforceable, it was likely that consumers who fulfilled the conditions stated in the ad could find that their own credit agreement would be unenforceable.”

The ASA says it had not seen evidence that supported the 70% claim, and so concluded that the claim was misleading.

On the second charge about upfront fees, the ASA judged that the advert should have made clear a fee would be payable.

The ASA ruled that the advert must not appear again in its current form. It welcomed the assurance from Unfair Credit Direct that it would not be advertising this service again in future.

Recommended

Post Office 90% LTV mortgages get cool reception from brokers

The Post Office has angered the broker community by launching a range of 90% LTV deals. The deals are funded through its joint venture with Bank of Ireland, which pulled out of the broker market at the beginning of 2009. In March business secretary Lord Peter Mandelson announced a significant expansion of the financial services […]

ADAM TYLER, CHIEF EXECUTIVE, NACFB

Recognise the role of female advisers

On June 30 we will be holding our annual conference at the Commercial Finance Expo in Birmingham. In a departure from our usual commercial finance-centric subjects one of the topics we will be covering is women in business. There is some debate around whether this is topic should stand on its own. Some say separating […]

Lender service has not improved in 34 years as an adviser

I feel compelled to vent my spleen with what I’m sure is a like-minded audience on the familiar subject of lender service. In 34 years of writing mortgage business I have to say that the standard of service offered by lenders at the moment is at best rubbish and at worst insulting. I am not […]

CHRISTOPHER TAYLOR, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, LONDON & EUROPEAN

Time for action to fill the policy gap

The general election has delivered the worst possible outcome – a hung Parliament. Arguments about the electoral system aside and whether the country voted for change given the percentage of votes cast, a hung Parliament means just one thing – uncertainty – and that’s the last thing we need. In taking the first faltering steps […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up