View more on these topics

Treasury consults on the way ahead for mutuals

Myners: government wants to ensure the future of mutuals because they add diversity and offer a strong business model
Myners: government wants to ensure the future of mutuals because they add diversity and offer a strong business model

The Treasury has published a discussion document setting out options for securing the long-term stability of the building society sector.

The paper seeks views from investors, members, societies and others on options for:

– New, more resilient capital instruments (ranking as core tier 1 or tier 1),
– Modifications to existing capital instruments to make them more resilient in times of economic stress,
– Enhancing the government’s role in supporting societies with regard to raising capital, including possible changes to legislation,
– Exploring whether capital instruments abroad should be adopted in the UK.

The Treasury acknowledges that societies have historically been well capitalised and the majority of mutuals have responded well to challenging conditions since the credit crisis began.

But it adds that the changed regulatory environment and increased competition in the market has highlighted a number of areas where reform could improve the resilience of the society model.

These include improving corporate governance and looking at different capital and funding models.

Paul Myners, financial services secretary to the Treasury, says: “Societies have long been at the heart of financial services in this country. The mutual sector encourages a diverse financial system and offers a strong business model. The government is keen to ensure that this remains the case in the longer term.

“I am confident that the range of options available will allow mutuals to increase their resilience to stress and give the sector the capacity to grow.”

He adds: “There is a need to consider whether the capital instruments currently available to societies are sufficient to ensure the longer term stability of the sector, as well as to explore alternatives and any changes that might be needed to introduce these.”

Adrian Coles, director-general of the Building Societies Association, says: “We welcome the publication of this discussion paper which seems to be well researched.

“It clearly identifies important issues surrounding core capital requirements for societies, specifically the need for a new tier 1 capital instrument that is compatible with the mutual model.”

He adds: “The Treasury has also effectively summarised the need for a mutual-compatible form of capital instrument that meets European Union regulatory requirements.”

Coles says the Treasury raises some interesting questions about a new form of capital instrument that could lead to institutional shareholders being entitled to a governance role at societies, while ensuring mutual values remain at the heart of their business.

He questions how this might change the existing mutual business model.

Coles adds: “We will take our time and put forward a considered response to the idea of developing a new core tier 1 capi- tal instrument.

“But this can only be a work in progress until European legislation is finalised and we can proceed with the certainty that a new instrument will not only meet the needs of the mutual model but also be compliant with all requirements.”

Recommended

1

Woolwich rejigs broker sales team

Woolwich is restructuring its intermediary sales team to provide different points of contact for brokers depending on how they want to deal with the lender. The move means 10 business managers have been moved to look after key accounts while 22 intermediary relationship managers have been appointed to deal with brokers face-to-face on a regional […]

Problems at Dunfermline rocked the mutual sector in 2009

Societies must keep it simple

According to some experts the troubled building society sector can emerge from the recession in good shape if it adheres to traditional values and methods, says Christine Toner

No sub-prime move in the pipeline, says Kensington

Kensington has rejected suggestions that its decision to consider applicants with County Court Judgements is a move towards reopening the sub-prime market. The lender has said it will consider customers who have had up to two CCJs totalling no more than £750 as long as these have been satisfied for more than six months. Kensington […]

9 October thumbnail

Johnson Fleming set to host webinar on auditing auto-enrolment schemes

With 23 auto-enrolment compliance notices issued by the Pensions Regulator, and an evolving legislative landscape meaning previously compliant schemes may now be in breach of regulation, now is the time to think about auditing your auto-enrolment scheme. Johnson Fleming is hosting a webinar on 9 October at 11:00 on how to audit your scheme to ensure compliance, avoid breaches and fines and overcome data issues.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up