View more on these topics

The Blindfolded Masochist

Two heads are supposedly better than one – but they can also be more destructive, as Michael Baxter argues in The Blindfolded Masochist.
The book’s tagline – “Creation versus destruction, the power of economic networks” – is somewhat misleading.

Although it is advertised as being about the economy and the financial crisis of 2008, this is not really the main theme of the book and it is more a philosophical look at how networks affect behaviour, society and our thinking.

The author argues that networks are guilty of steering society in the wrong direction and are responsible for the financial crisis.

According to Baxter, networks exist all around us and can be made up of anything that forms a collective, ranging from people and animals to cells.

To illustrate the destructive nature of networks, Baxter uses the example of a massive shoal of sardines navigating their way through the Pacific Ocean.

They swam in tight formation and seemed to have a collective intelligence. They navigated into Redondo Beach’s King harbour, California, but failed to reverse course and got trapped in their own creation – sucking all the oxygen supply from the shallow waters and suffocating en masse.

Baxter also uses bankers to illustrate how networks can be destructive.

Before the credit crunch, the action of one banker in isolation was not dangerous but when the model of securitisation was copied by a network of bankers it became destructive.

He argues that individuals in a collective are less likely to question what they are doing and tend to assume that someone in the group is in the know.

Baxter is not against networks, but thinks they need to harness their power for good. The brain, for example, is a successful network made up of around 100 trillion connections, which could not achieve alone what they do together.

Baxter argues that in today’s society, using networks correctly has never been more important, especially with the advent of the internet, which he predicts will fuel their growth.

The book is short and easy to read, despite touching on issues that are at times complex and technical.

The author uses examples throughout the chapters to illustrate his thinking, but while these are useful at times, he tends to overdo it.

His references often add nothing to his point and break the reader’s flow. Because the book is technical and complicated in places, the extensive use of references can make it hard to follow. Baxter does make some interesting observations, however, about the pros and cons of networks, but he doesn’t really go into enough detail about what can be done to rectify the problems they can cause.

He touches on the solution near the end of the book with the conclusion that education is the way forward and individuals need to start thinking for themselves in order to gain benefit from working within networks.

The book is at times rather one-sided and does not present much food for thought from an opposing perspective.

But at 160 pages, The Blindfolded Masochist is worth a read, especially for those in an industry such as the mortgage market, which relies on networks functioning correctly. If anything, it might provide a useful reminder that following the crowd is not always the best thing to do.

Book review by Natalie Thomas


Paper shows FSA is at last listening to the industry

I am delighted to see in its latest Mortgage Market Review paper that the Financial Services Authority has moved on from its utopian ideas and woolly rhetoric, so common in its publications, to produce a set of practical and well thought out proposals. I am particularly pleased that at last it has stood up to […]

Coventry offers ERC-free letting deals

Coventry Intermediaries has launched a new range of mortgage products, including some five-year buy-to-let deals with no early repayment charges. The lender is introducing a buy-to-let five-year fix at 5.35%, which is available up to 75% LTV with a £250 booking fee and £999 arrangement fee, and no ERCs.It is also offering the same product […]


Pension over-taxing

800,000 people are at risk of being over-taxed on their pensions, writes Steve Webb, director of policy at Royal London Hundreds of thousands of people receiving company and personal pensions should check their tax code to make sure that they are not being over-taxed, according to a leading pensions firm. Mutual insurer Royal London has […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up