View more on these topics

Portman branded a Judas

A protest group set up to mobilise Portman’s members against its proposed merger with Nationwide has branded the society a Judas for agreeing to the sale.

Calling themselves Members Against The Takeover, the group recently placed an advert in the Daily Mail calling on members to “vote no to the proposed Nationwide takeover of Portman”.

It also directs members to its website,, where they can download a letter to Martin Stanley, chief executive of the Competition Commission, registering an objection to the proposal.

The website includes a poster for Portman staff to use, which states: “The potential takeover of Portman by Nationwide is not in the interests of the members or staff of the society, or the building society movement as a whole. Portman must remain true to its heritage and stay fully independent.”

The website features two cartoon strips illustrating its feelings about the merger.

In one, Nationwide chief executive Philip Williamson is pictured imagining writing off building societies as “things of the past” and suggests killing off Portman to create a huge structure “a bit like the Millennium Dome”. Portman’s chief executive Robert Sharpe asks: “But isn’t that large and completely empty of purpose?” to which Williamson responds with glee: “Yes, but members will never notice once they get their cheques.”

In the other, two small boys compare the merger to biblical stories. One says his dad is for the merger because “like the Bible says, you always have to make the most of yourself.” The other quips his mum thinks its like the Bible too – the story of Judas.

Paul Howard, director of intermediary sales at Portman and The Mortgage Works, says: “We are holding member meetings with Sharpe in attendance so people can have their say, and we would be delighted to meet the people behind”

Howard says this protest isn’t a sign that the vote concerning the merger will be a resounding no.

He adds: “Some people will be sad to see the independence of Portman go, hence the need for a vote. But the vast majority will be happy to take the money and still be members of a mutual.”

A spokesman for Nationwide says it believes the merger is good news for members of both societies but declined to comment further about the protest group.

An anonymous member of Members Against The Takeover says: “This is a battle that can be won.”

Recommended launches

New sourcing system has launched to the industry.It has been developed by broker SmartMove, and it sources the deal, underwrites the application and produces a KFI along with compliance research. It provides intermediaries with details of specific lenders and specific mortgage deals available to their clients along with reasons for the product choice for […]

Blackwell quits

Mark Blackwell has quit The Derbyshire after two and a half years as marketing director.

Edeus says it will be five years before serious industry nasties are exposed

Edeus has predicted it will be five years before what it calls the “real nasties” in the market are exposed. Alan Cleary, managing director of edeus, warns that the Financial Services Authority’s recent spate of fines was just the tip of the iceberg. He says: “I think it will take about five years before the […]

HIPs are doomed and this discredited, naive government should drop them now

From Trevor Kent The welcome call from the Council of Mortgage Lenders – a body that both Blair and Brown take notice of – to abandon Home Information Packs is timely indeed. Only last month the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors said just about the same thing and the National Association of Estate Agents has […]


Case study: administration — implementing a management log

Our client is a leading video game and publishing company best known for its console role-playing game franchises. The client provides a number of benefits, at varying levels and cost that attract a P11d liability. With the absence of a management log to track data for benefit movements, enormous administrative and therefore cost implications were occurring each year just to comply with P11d reporting requirements.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up