View more on these topics

Guarantee scheme won’t attract private backing

So, the old Mortgage Indemnity Guarantee scheme is said be making a comeback in a new form, with the government – i.e. taxpayers like you and I – underwriting the risk.

The lessons about risk sharing and fair pricing of the late 1980s and early 1990s indicate there could be an argument for private insurance companies to enter this market rather than further burden the public purse. But the key issue is capital.

The requirement for capital to be set aside against the risk of the next economic downturn is too great for private companies unless the risks involved are specifically defined.

Lenders must recognise that they have to pay the correct price and share the appropriate risk with underwriters and borrowers.

I fear the economics will not stack up. Customers will not be prepared to pay more for their mortgages either through higher insurance premiums or through more accurate risk-based pricing of loans.

And if the government steps in, where is the money going to come from? It sounds as if it is planning to use public money to underpin lenders with little or no prospect of making a return on this investment, and there is always the possibility of making a massive loss – ask anyone who wrote MIG cover last time around.

The fact is that lenders must rebuild their capital bases before they can enter into risky high LTV lending. At least with the current government intervention in the banking sector there is some prospect of taxpayers recouping their losses.

Rob Hayes



By email


Dream on

Mole particularly liked a spoof April Fool picture from the Daily Mail, which showed a lookalike home secretary Jacqui Smith coming out of an Ann Summers shop clutching a large shopping bag. Maybe Smith was trying to inject a little spice into her love life after her husband admitted claiming adult movies on her MPs expenses.

HSBC will use its market muscle to cross-sell to clients

I’m worried by the news that John Charcol is to have advisers in HSBC branches. HSBC has the power to get everyone into its branches and cross-sell to them. I can’t see how any broker can compete.

HML to manage Scarborough Mortgage Services

Scarborough Mortgage Services is to be managed by Homeloan Management following the merger of the Scarborough and Skipton building societies this week.

Brexit and the mid cap buying opportunities

Video update from Mark Martin, Head of UK Equities, Neptune Investment Management With the Brexit referendum scheduled for 23 June, how much risk is priced into the market and is the current volatility a long-term buying opportunity? Watch Mark Martin, Head of UK Equities, and Holly Cassell, Assistant Manager on the UK Mid Cap and […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up