View more on these topics

Shadow MPC – June 2012

Cutting the base rate is not an option as while it would ease pressure on borrowers it would pile it on for the banks. With a brighter outlook for inflation further quantitative easing is not necessary yet, but that could change if Eurogeddon comes

This Month’s Decision: HOLD

The Bank’s base rate has been at its historic low of 0.5% for just over 5% of the Queen’s reign but as the euro’s unravelling gathers pace, its collateral damage is rapidly escalating. It would be a brave person who bet against that 5% not hitting double figures.

Christine Lagarde, managing director of the International Monetary Fund, has suggested that the UK Bank rate should be cut further. This, coupled with her comment that the Greeks should pay their taxes – a rather hypocritical remark when she pays none on her salary – has meant that the assumption that the next move in Bank base rate would be upwards, with the only question when, is now being challenged in a few quarters.

A base rate cut to 0.25%, or maybe even zero, would be great news for those with a tracker mortgage or an SVR capped for term at 2% over Bank base rate. However, it would put many bank and building society balance sheets under further pressure. That would increase the risk of a rate increase for borrowers not protected by any guarantees.

Thus the consequence of cutting Bank base rate would be to reduce mortgage costs for borrowers who, in general, already have the lowest rates and are under the least financial pressure. This is at the risk of a little further down the road increasing costs for borrowers, including many mortgage prisoners, who are more likely to be under pressure. So it is hard to see what boxes a base rate cut would tick.

Although the UK’s latest monthly retail sales figures have shone a little light on the generally gloomy economic outlook, all the indications are that monetary policy will need to continue to be accommodating for the foreseeable future.

The main debate this month should not be about whether the Bank base rate needs to change but whether to increase quantitative easing.

The fairly sharp fall in the oil price recently has improved the inflation outlook, which reduces concerns about more QE stoking it up.

Although the UK economy hasn’t changed much in the last month the risk of infection from the dark clouds of Eurogeddon has.

The Bank needs to keep some ammunition available to react rapidly to further negative developments on the euro front line – it won’t have to worry about how to react to positive developments. So I vote this month to leave both Bank rate and the QE programme unchanged but to be prepared for a rapid response to developments if necessary before the July meeting.

More QE may well be appropriate as part of the response to further shock waves from the eurozone but different, and perhaps untried, policies may also be necessary. Now is the time to consider options and their relative pros and cons.


Ray Boulger
Senior technical manager, John Charcol
Decision: Hold


Mehrdad Yousefi
Industry consultant
Decision: Hold



Dev Malle
Sales director, Personal Touch Financial Services
Decision: Hold



Vic Jannels
Chairman, All Types of Mortgages
Decision: Hold



John Cupis
Managing director, PMS
Decision: Hold




Mark Harris
chief executive, SPF private clients
Decision: Hold



Peter Williams
Executive Director, IMLA
Decision: Hold




David Finlay
Managing director for mortgages, Barclays
Decision: Hold



Fahim Antoniades
Group director, Mortgage Centre IFA
Decision: Hold



Lloyds group top-ups need whole loan repayment plan

Lloyds Banking Group borrowers with an interest-only mortgage who are looking for a further advance will now have to supply evidence of a repayment plan for the entire loan. Previously, Lloyds group asked borrowers to provide evidence of a repayment method only for the extra that they sought on the loan. But, from May 28, […]

20% Rise in young adults still living with parents

Almost three million adults aged between 20 and 34 were living with their parents last year, increasing by almost half a million, or 20%, since 1997. The number of people in this age group was the same in both 1997 and 2011. Figures from the Office for National Statistics show that at age 20, 64% […]

Pension funds urged to help capital build homes

Visiting the offices of the Coreco Group to discuss apprenticeships Johnson promised to host a round table on encouraging institutional investors into property. He also outlined plans to release more than 500 hectares of public land for development in a plan to get London building homes. Johnson says: “We have to build more homes in […]

Pensions - thumbnail

Changes to capped drawdown tables

The tables used for capped drawdown maximum income calculations have been updated. We look at the reasons for the change and what the impact could be. Changes to capped drawdown tables Capped income drawdown involves taking a pension directly from a fund instead of buying an annuity. However, there’s a limit on the maximum amount […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up
  • Post a comment
  • Michael White MD Boutique Capital 7th June 2012 at 12:04 pm

    Economic grief is not being caused by tight monetary policy, supply side reforms are still desperately needed. A finely-balanced decision as clearer evidence emerges of contagion from the financial crisis to the real economy.