View more on these topics

Even FSA-approved trail commission would be too much of a risk for brokers

Mortgage Strategy’s cover story in the May 21 issue entitled ‘Trouble with fees’ informed the industry debate which is probably more fervent than any other at the moment.

Even writing from the tranquillity of my garden, I feel I have to take issue with some of the points made by Keith Butler. Going by Butler’s job title of mortgage analyst I assume he represents neither a broker nor a lender. That may explain some naive thinking on his part.

First, why should the payment of proc fees leave brokers open to misselling claims? The charging of proc fees is now transparent so borrowers can see what brokers are being paid for their services by lenders. Of course, proc fees are not paid for services to clients.

Second, Butler suggests the absence of an industry riposte to Alliance & Leicester chief executive Richard Pym’s assertion in 2004 that lenders other than A&L were only enjoying more business because they were paying out higher proc fees was suspicious. Here, Butler’s logic is as flawed as it is insulting to other lenders.

Regarding Pym, I find it ironic that A&L’s then head of intermediary mortgages Mehrdad Yousefi – the man probably most responsible for A&L’s gargantuan strides in the mortgage market over the past 10 years or so – was not saying the same things as his chief executive. Then as now, he knows better. Gaps in lenders’ loan originations are a result of either service issues or uncompetitive product offerings, not rivals’ proc fee strategies.

Even before statutory regulation, the Mortgage Code Compliance Board was adhered to by the vast majority of brokers – in the prime sector, at least. Even then, brokers knew that recommending a product purely on the strength of commission was a serious misdemeanour.

I respect Butler for trying to propose alternatives to the existing commission model but both his ideas are dubious. First, why lenders would agree to a standardisation of fees in a commercial and cutthroat sector such as mortgages is beyond me, especially with so many lender entrants coming into the market.

Why should a lender that has invested heavily and judiciously in technology to cut costs and drive efficiency wave away an advantage by not being able to outperform fatter lenders with regard to the proc fees it offers to brokers? We’ll see communities secretary Ruth Kelly become head of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors before we see commission payments standardised.

His second suggestion – that lenders agree to pay us nothing for finding clients, sourcing the right products for them and taking responsibility for the advice we give – has as much chance of becoming a reality as Gordon Brown has of discovering the art of plain speaking.

That said, I agree with Butler that while not quite broken, the mortgage model needs re-engineering. Many lenders would love to defeat mortgage churn and many brokers would have no problem with a form of Financial Services Authority-approved trail commission that would embed greater value in their businesses.

But to achieve this, brokers would have to overcome the short-term cash flow challenges surrounding a reduction in upfront proc fees in return for a carried interest in the value of a lender’s loan book. It could happen, but it would mean brokers and lenders jumping over a financial cliff together. That could be daunting for brokers.

Kevin Duffy
Managing director (designate)
Robert Sterling Group
By email


Merger threat to surveyors

Small surveyor firms could be forced to consolidate if rum-ours that e.surv is looking to incorporate Barclays’ surveying and valuation firm Ekins and Cheltenham & Gloucester’s valuations arm prove to be true.Last week, sources close to the deal revealed that if it takes place e.surv will instantly secure more than 30% of the surveying market, […]

Towergate sale could net founder 2bn

Towergate founder Peter Cullum could pocket up to 2bn if he takes up one of several acquisition bids made by private equity firms last week.Cullum, who last month bagged third place in Mortgage Strategy’s Rich List of industry players, owns a 65% stake in Towergate, which he launched 10 years ago. In November last year […]

Another index to add to our confusion

It’s difficult to see why we need another property price index. We’ve already got data coming out our ears from numerous respected – and sometimes not so respected – organisations and financial institutions which should be giving us as much information as we need about the state of the housing market in general and house prices in particular.

Rule change boost for equity release

The government’s plan to scrap the need to get planning permission for minor home improvements could boost the equity release market, says In Retirement Services. It estimates 47% of its clients use equity release to fund home improvements.

Don’t play chicken with the Bank of Japan

By Josh Ausden, Head of Client Investment Strategy, Neptune Short-term yen strength has hurt the Neptune Japan Opportunities Fund but recent events have only added weight to our conviction that the Bank of Japan will act to ease policy, boosting multinationals’ profits and weakening the yen. In recent weeks the performance of the Japanese stockmarket […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up