View more on these topics

Education needed, not regulation, say compliance experts

Research says the government, not the Financial Services Authority, should be responsible for financial education

Over 70% of financial services compliance experts believe consumer education is more important than tighter regulation when it comes to reducing mis-selling.

The findings are based on research by Huntswood Outsourcing Solutions, conducted in conjunction with Financial World, the magazine of the Institute of Financial Services.

The survey of 134 financial advisors dealing with mis-selling claims also reveals that 91% believe educating children in the basics of personal finance should be made compulsory in schools, in the same way as sex education.

David Brownlow, chief executive of Huntswood Outsourcing Solutions, says: “The role of consumer ignorance and consequent mis-buying in the widespread mis-selling problems we have in this country is borne out by the fact that currently only 40% of complaints to the Ombudsman in relation to mortgage endowment mis-selling are ruled in the policyholder&#39s favour.

Huntswood&#39s view, and that of the overwhelming majority of those directly involved in dealing with mis-selling claims, is that consumer education, not tighter regulation, is the main factor that will reduce mis-selling problems.”

Responsibility for personal finance education lies with the Financial Services Authority, which has pledged to cut back on its supervisory work to focus more effort on improving consumer understanding. However, 71% of the compliance experts surveyed think the government should take direct responsibility for financial education, with a public education programmefunded by the Exchequer.

The FSA&#39s budget for consumer education is small, representing less than 5% of its total expenditure.

Brownlow adds: “Mis-selling claims are not the only problems associated with consumers&#39 financial illiteracy; there is also the savings gap and the ever-increasing mountain of consumer debt. Financial literacy is therefore an issue of central economic importance and it is absurd that a government department is not directly responsible for it.

One suspects the government&#39s decision to devolve responsibility for financial education to the FSA was motivated primarily by a desire to shift the associated cost on to the financial services industry, which funds the FSA.”

Recommended

Retail sales growth points to rate rise

Retail sales grew solidly in October, rising at their fastest year-on-year rate for 18 months, business leaders reported yesterday, prompting fears that the Bank of England will raise interest rates this week. Figures from the Confederation of British Industry show sales grew in September but by less than had been expected. October&#39s performance was much […]

Digest Call to raise duty threshold

The CML has criticised the government for failing to raise the £60,000 Stamp Duty threshold, claiming an additional 138,000 homebuyers will be liable to pay the tax this year. In its pre-Budget submission, the CML says the failure of successive governments to raise the threshold for more than a decade means it is now a […]

Zurich theatre to publicise network at Mortgage Expo

Zurich has built a 96-seat theatre known as The Zurich Mortgage Network Theatre from which it will run a two-day seminar programme at this year&#39s Mortgage Business Expo. Zurich, sponsors of the Expo, is aiming to attract intermediaries to its mortgage network at this year&#39s show, taking place at Earls Court on November 18 and […]

Marketplace tells borrowers not to worry about potential rise in rate

David Bitner, head of product operations at The MarketPlace at Bradford & Bingley, says borrowers should not be overly concerned about a rise in interest rates. He says: “They are more than likely to be moderate, but to think that many borrowers will just ignore the rise is worrying.” Bitner adds that what is really […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up