View more on these topics

Was Zurich action needed?

Last week Mortgage Strategy reported the dispute between Home of Choice and Zurich had been settled out of court.

The companies released a joint statement that read: “Legal proceedings between Openwork and Zurich against Home of Choice, Richard Coulson and Gerry O’Brien have been settled on commercial terms.”

Both Coulson and O’Brien had been due to face their former employer Zurich in the High Court of Justice over allegations that Coulson, a former Zurich Mortgage Network director, was still in the employment of Zurich while he was promoting his network Home of Choice.

So, this week Mortgage Strategy asks: “Was Zurich’s court action against HoC a waste of time and money?”
Jonathan Cornell, Hamptons International Mortgages – Although a contract stipulates what employees can and can’t do, if it becomes clear they have transgressed it and the employer wishes to take action, the costs and time involved make it hard to see what the firm gets out of it.

Christopher May, The Mortgage Times Group – If an employee is deemed by the employer to be in breach of their contract then it’s only right for them to take court action. This is obviously what Zurich felt in regard to Home of Choice. The outcome in this case is that we don’t actually now know who was right and who was wrong but I hope both parties can put this sour case behind them and concentrate on their propositions.

Richard Griffiths, Network Data – Employer-employee relationships always start out with the best of intentions. On his appointment to the Zurich Mortgage Network in November 2003, Coulson was quoted as saying, “I can see no reason why I will not end my career here.” Well, he found a reason to leave, and at that point there is a duty of care to his employer. I do not know the specifics of the Zurich/Coulson situation, but I do subscribe to the saying that there is no smoke without fire. Zurich felt aggrieved enough to initiate the court action and take out an injunction. Draw your own conclusions.

James Rodea, Cluttons – This is a tricky one. If a contract is entered into in good faith then it should be kept, and you shouldn’t try to take clients away from a company that is paying you. However, I am against employers enforcing parts of contracts and making employees stick around just because they can. They should just cut the ties, say, “Thanks, you were great,” and let them be on their way.

Jonathan Burridge, Quantum – When influential senior staff exit any organisation it is similar to ending an emotional relationship – in circumstances where the reasons for the break up are not clear cut or there are fights over belongings, it can make the separation acrimonious. While the details of the settlement in this case are confidential, it seems that one of the parties realised the futility of chasing the other around the courtroom and throwing plates at them, which truly would have been a waste of money.

David Copland, Pink Home Loans – I am sure this case was worth it for the lawyers involved. But seriously, both parties had their points of view and business interests to protect. I’m sure there have been things to learn for both Coulson and Zurich during this process.

Sally Laker, Mortgage Intelligence – Where someone is genuinely aggrieved – whether it is a person or a company or employer – they have a right to take whatever action is appropriate. No doubt Zurich would have taken advice both commercially and legally, as this type of action would only be taken after much consideration.

Recommended

Kensington launches insurance range

Kensington Mortgages has launched its insurance range, developed as the complimentary partner to its mortgage product range. Kensingtons insurance range offers features and flexibility to meet the needs of its borrowers. The range comprises of household building insurance, with or without contents, accident and sickness, or accident, sickness and unemployment insurance. Kensington listened to introducer […]

Fannie Mae to apply comforming loan limits

Fannie Mae, the New York Stock Exchange company, has revealed it will apply conforming loan limits, as determined by the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight based on federal data on average home prices, to increase its single-family mortgage loan limit to $417,000 for 2006.As a result of the loan limit, Fannie Mae estimates that […]

Clydesdale named best overall mortgage lender

Clydesdale Bank has been named best overall mortgage lender at the Hamptons Mortgage awards ceremony, within a year of entering the mortgage intermediary market. The award was presented at the Hamptons awards ceremony at The Cafe Royal in London on Thursday November 24. Kevin Lilley, head of national accounts for third party distribution at Clydesdale […]

Freedom Lending signs 50% deal with MPLC

Freedom Lending, the Wilmslow based specialist mortgage lender, has agreed with Mortgages PLC to sell at least 50% of its mortgage production during 2006. The flow agreement enables MPLC to accelerate the growth of its mortgage book, while giving Freedom Lending the confidence to boost its mortgage sales knowing it has a guaranteed buyer of […]

Life cover for life

Jennifer Gilchrist Proposition Lead – Design, Royal London When someone mentions whole of life plans, most people will think of a niche product that serves as an inheritance tax planning tool for high-net-worth clients. And it’s really not surprising they’ve been pigeonholed in that way because before the arrival of RDR in 2013, that’s more […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up