View more on these topics

FSA talks big but delivers little, says CA

The Consumers&#39 Association has warned that the Financial Services Authority&#39s latest proposals on with-profits will do little to protect the 10 million with-profit policyholders who are saving for a pension, or paying off their mortgage with an endowment policy.

Today&#39s proposals will not introduce real corporate governance oraccountability, and will not prevent directors being able to put shareholders interests before policyholders.

Unlike a unit trust where consumers&#39 money is held separately in trust reducing the opportunity for abuse by directors, when consumers hand over money to a with-profits company the actual legal ownership then resides with the life insurance company putting them in a vulnerable position. Policyholders who are unhappy with the treatment they receive will then face huge penalties if they wish to surrender.

Despite the reforms, directors will still be able to set the rules and effectively judge themselves on how they treat and consumers. Consumers in turn will remain without meaningful legal or regulatory protection.

The reforms will not prevent previous examples of corporate abuse including: Axa type raids on orphan assets which costs policyholders hundreds of millions of pounds; ompanies using policyholder funds to pay compensation costs for corporate wrongdoing such as pensions mis-selling or endowment mis-selling; manipulation by directors of with-profits funds at the cost ofpolicyholders; distortion of competition, by the big with-profits using policyholders funds to cross subsidise land grabs for market share and to snuff out competition from better value providers.

Mick McAteer, senior policy adviser at the Consumers&#39 Association, says: “Once again the FSA is making rather meaningless sweeping gestures on with-profits which will do little to protect policyholders and could even strengthen the position of directors.

“The FSA missed a golden opportunity to embark on a fundamental overhaul of this market that would have given legal protection for consumers and created new structures to ensure real corporate accountability for industry. Regrettably today&#39s proposals are half-hearted measures relating mainly to transparency. More transparency will of course be welcome but alone it will offer little protection to the ten million consumers who are currently trapped in these funds”

Recommended

Homebuyers holding off as market slows, says RICS

House hunters are holding off buying property until they can see which way the market is moving. The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors&#39 housing market survey for the final quarter of 2002 shows that potential buyers have put their plans on hold while waiting to see whether house prices will fall dramatically or whether the […]

One in five Brits suffer financial phobia

&#39Financial phobia&#39 is a genuine psychological condition for one-fifth of Britons who struggle to manage their finances, internet bank Egg says. Academics at Cambridge University identify several symptoms of an ailment they say affects over 9 million Britons. These include not opening bank statements; never checking bank balances; and, in the most extreme cases, throwing […]

New BDM at Commercial First

Commercial First, the latest entrant to join the ranks of specialist lenders in the UK, has appointed Stephen Kisby as its business development manager in the North and the Midlands. Kisby joins Commercial First&#39s sales team from Mortgageforce, where he was one of the company&#39s most respected and successful regional development managers. He spent almost […]

Retail savings market sees growth

The European retail savings and investments market has grown 8.1% over the period 1997-2001, a report from Datamonitor reveals. The UK accounts for the largest market share, followed by Germany. Retail deposits is the largest sector, driven by households increasing savings due to the slowdown of the global economy. The UK holds the largest retail […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up