View more on these topics

Consumer Panel calls for review of law on financial advertising

The Financial Services Consumer Panel has highlighted legal restrictions on the FSA which the panel says are harming more consumers than they help.

Colin Brown, chairman of the panel, has written to FSA chairman Howard Davies, setting out the Panel&#39s concerns.

As the law stands, once the FSA has received a complaint about an advertisement or any other promotion it is not allowed to say anything about its opinion on that promotion until a full enforcement process has been gone through, which may take months or even years. In many instances, the FSA simply persuades a firm to withdraw a potentially misleading advertisement rather than go through the lengthy enforcement process. In those cases, consumers may never be told that they may have been subjected to misleading promotional material.

These constraints were put into the system when the FSA was set up under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. They were intended to protect the reputation of firms when they are investigated by the FSA, but no decision is made against them. However, the Consumer Panel does not think that the current unwieldy system is appropriate or effective in dealing with the fast moving world of advertising.

The current arrangements for bringing misleading financial promotions to the attention of the public stand in stark contrast to those for advertising from other sectors. The Advertising Standards Authority takes an average of 21 days to resolve complaints and publishes its decisions on its website, where they are regularly picked up by the media, government and other interest groups. There is no such facility available to protect consumers in the often complicated decision-making process for financial products and services.

The FSA has responsibility for policing financial advertising and other promotions, to ensure that they meet the “clear, fair and not misleading” standard. The Consumer Panel has been pressing the FSA for some time now to make more of these powers and to encourage consumers to complain about material which they do not think meet those standards. The Panel was pleased with the FSA&#39s initiative at the beginning of this month, to use the media and their website to promote their powers and explain how consumers can alert the FSA to financial promotional material which they believe to be misleading. The Panel looks forward to seeing continuing action from the FSA in this crucial area for consumers.

However, there is a commitment for FSMA to be reviewed by HM Treasury from two years after N2 (December 1 2003). The Consumer Panel wants the FSA to start thinking now about how the legislation could be changed to allow more details to be released about problems with financial advertising and/or the legal enforcement process to be speeded up.

Colin Brown says: “Consumers should have a better warning system than currently exists for misleading financial promotions. It is exactly the kind of problem that the review of FSMA will need to tackle after the Act has been working for two years. We are raising this issue now so that we can get ideas on how to improve the system on the table early.”

Recommended

Great service? Beat this

From Marc TurnerRegarding Gary Booth&#39s letter in your January 13 issue concerning Northern Rock&#39s excellent turnaround time, I feel this may be the catalyst for a &#39standards of service&#39 competition. My compliments go to Abbey National for the following incredible example: appointment at the client&#39s house on November 6, 2002, subsequently submitted online later that […]

New BDM at Commercial First

Commercial First, the latest entrant to join the ranks of specialist lenders in the UK, has appointed Stephen Kisby as its business development manager in the North and the Midlands. Kisby joins Commercial First&#39s sales team from Mortgageforce, where he was one of the company&#39s most respected and successful regional development managers. He spent almost […]

Surge in e-business for adviser.tech exhibitors

Adviser.tech exhibitors including Norwich Union, Legal & General and Webline have all reported significant growth in their online business in the past few months. Norwich Union saw its e-business increase 47% in the second half of 2002, with 86% of this coming via the company&#39s own extranet service Since its launch in April 2002 Legal […]

Homebuyers holding off as market slows, says RICS

House hunters are holding off buying property until they can see which way the market is moving. The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors&#39 housing market survey for the final quarter of 2002 shows that potential buyers have put their plans on hold while waiting to see whether house prices will fall dramatically or whether the […]

How to balance bottom-up with top-down research in constructing multi-asset credit portfolios

In this short video, Azhar Hussain, head of global high yield at Royal London Asset Management, explains how his team balance bottom-up with top-down research in constructing multi-asset credit portfolios. Watch the video in full The value of investments and the income from them is not guaranteed and may go down as well as up […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up