View more on these topics

Case sparks disclosure fears

Buy-to-let could be the first casualty in the wake of the recent court ruling on the non-disclosure of commission payments.

In the case of Hurstanger versus Wilson, secured loan borrower Delroy Wilson took lender Hurst- anger to court over a commission pay-ment it made to his broker.

Wilson claimed his original contract with the lender was void because a £240 commission payment had not been disclosed.

The court decided against voiding the loan contract, describing it as fair and enforceable, but ruled that commission should be disclosed to alert consumers about potential conflicts of interest.

Hurstanger was forced to pay Wilson the original commission of £240 plus interest of 1.29% a month dating back to August 2003.

An industry expert warns that the case could lead to a flood of similar claims, in particular from so-called ambulance chaser firms targeting products that do not come under the Financial Services Authority’s remit. Products like buy-to-let and secured loans, where the disclosure of commission isn’t mandatory, are believed to be partic- ularly at risk.

The source says: “While some buy-to-let lenders offer full disclosure, many don’t. It’s one of the consequences of the sector being unregulated.

“Any business that doesn’t do Key Facts Illustrations or full disclosures could find itself facing claims.”

A spokeswoman for BM Solutions says: “We treat buy-to-let like a regulated market but some players aren’t in a position to do so.”

But John Heron, director of mortgages at Paragon Mortgages, says: “I’ve never come across any issue raised by borrowers or brokers relating to the non-disclosure of commission.”

He says that while disclosure is not mandatory in buy-to-let, the majority of sales are made by FSA-regulated firms that do so as a matter of course.

He adds: “There’s no benefit from non-disclosure. Those firms that aren’t FSA-regulated tend to be members of the National Association of Commercial Finance Brokers and its code of practice demands disclosure.”

Recommended

Exclusive deals from Kensington

Kensington has launched two exclusive deals offering fees-free remortgages and fixed rates from 5.55%. The fees-free package is available on three-year fixed rate sub-prime applications submitted direct to Kensington and through selected distributors.

MS Online readers want the plug pulled on HIPs

Despite protests from the Association of Home Information Pack Providers and Whitehall, the mortgage industry is still hostile to HIPs.A massive 86% of Mortgage Strategy Online readers believe the government should pull the plug on the packs.This week, Mortgage Strategy asks: “Has the government spent too much on advertising HIPs?” Q: Should the government pull […]

20% Of owners will sell homes for retirement

One in five adults expect to have to sell their homes to finance their re-tirement, a study by Prudential has revealed. The firm’s research shows five million adults of working age believe they will never be able to afford to retire while two-thirds expect the income from their state pension to have dec-reased in relative […]

Firm sounds buy-to-let repossessions warning

Moore Blatch has forecast a sharp rise in buy-to-let repossessions as re- cent interest rate rises start to affect landlords.The repossession litigation specialist says repossessions have flattened over the past year, but warns that the market could see a significant upswing in them as both buy-to-let and owner-occupier borrowers begin to feel the pinch of […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up