View more on these topics

Big may be beautiful but flexibility is better

There has been plenty of talk about the advantages of size in recent months.

The probability and timing of consolidation in the mortgage network, sub-prime lender and building society sectors have all been discussed.

The underlying presumption has been that big is beautiful or at least gives you an edge over the competition. Witness the talk about the merger between Nationwide and Portman for a classic example of people presuming that greater size will equal greater competitiveness.

And yet we have also seen a number of new entrants, particularly into the sub-prime lending market, which have started from scratch. Meanwhile, the long predicted round of consolidation seems to be a long time coming.

So how much does size really matter?

Clearly there are advantages to being large. The economies of scale suggest that there should be cost advantages, in particular through fixed costs being spread across more output units.

This includes inv-estment in elements such as computer systems and marketing. In many negotiating situations, size gives the power to demand better terms whether it be with suppliers, for funding or exclusive products, or distributors.

But size certainly isn’t everything. Producing the right inno-vations and being responsive and flexible are far more important in most situations.

This means understanding what your customers want and being able to deliver it better than the competition. Having investment funding is important in this respect, favouring large organisations, but the insight to invest the money wisely is more important. After all, innovation and responsiveness can be hindered by greater size, for example because of lack of coordination between departments.

It is often a question of timing. While a market is still maturing and developing, size is not all it’s cracked up to be. Getting the right innovation can allow a company to achieve growth quickly in such a situation.

But as a market becomes more settled, products and services be-come more standardised and margins get lower. Then size starts to matter a lot more.

That is why in any market’s life there comes a period of consolidation when innovation becomes less important and firms look to reap the cost advantages of size.

And, as a market settles, leaders tend to emerge that have the power to buy smaller firms or force them out of business.

This settling down has not happened yet either in the mortgage network or the sub-prime markets. These are still developing, with innovation being more important than price. The latest wave of sub-prime lenders have shown this by triggering a spurt in innovation.

And the market for networks is even more youthful, with the opportunity for any company to grab the initiative, particularly in terms of computer systems.

Both of these markets – but particularly networks – will benefit from development as their products and services deliver more value to their customers.

Meanwhile, those expecting immediate or rapid consolidation will be frustrated for a while longer.

Recommended

RICS joins Tenancy Deposit Scheme

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors has been approved as part of the Dispute Service component of the Department for Communities and Local Government’s Tenancy Deposit Scheme.Gillian Charlesworth, head of regulation policy at RICS, says: “RICS is delighted to be approved as part of Dispute Service component of the DCLG’s Tenancy Deposit Scheme, thus obtaining […]

Media is looking for bad news in the property market

From Michael Curran We all know how attached we Britons are to home ownership and also how press and television companies love to produce copy and programmes regarding the joys and pitfalls of the one financial and lifestyle aspiration we all share. But what is beginning to worry me is the switch in the national […]

Trustguard appoints staff

Trustguard Credit Services Ltd has appointed of six new staff members.The new faces at Trustguard are Chris Bishop, who has joined as mortgage underwriter, Jason Spice, loan relationship manager, trainee mortgage underwriters Craig Smith and Lee Sullivan and Laura Moulton and Tracy Morgan, who are appointed loan underwriters. Training of the new staff will be […]

Scarborough launches sub-prime range

Scarborough is to offer its sub-prime products to the wider broker market earlier than planned. Scarborough Specialist Mortgages is planning to make its new sub-prime products available to all brokers. The product range offers rates ranging from 5.29% on prime loans to 6.49% on adverse buy-to-let mortgages.Tony Burdin, head of group marketing at Scarborough, says: […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up