View more on these topics

FSA should not instil fear says CML

Speaking at the Council of Mortgage Lenders Annual Lunch 2009 today, Matthew Wyles, chairman of the CML says it is not the right way forward for the FSA to want to be feared.

FSA chief executive Hector Sants warned in March that people should be frightened of the regulator.

But Wyles says: “I would support robust action where individual firms have got it wrong and their customers have suffered. A culture of mutual respect will be more potent than one based on fear.”

He also called for a more adult and open relationship between regulated firms and the regulator.

He says: “If we throw the innovation baby out with the toxic asset bathwater, we will end up with a market that functions less well.

“Put another way, what we need is a more adult and open relationship between regulated firms and the regulator in which there can be an informed debate about business developments before they happen, not a slap on the wrist after the event as the FSA decides it does not like the outcome (with the benefit of hindsight).”

For a competitive, innovative and vibrant mortgage market to return, he says we need more diversity – small lenders as well as large ones, specialist lenders as well as banks and building societies.

He does not want to see a UK banking system which is more hidebound by liquidity, capital and credit risk controls than its international peers – that would not be good for UK plc either.

He says: “I think we’d all recognise that what we do want is market that behaves, and is encouraged to behave, more rationally than it did in the recent past. Competition is vital to achieving positive outcomes for consumers, right up to the point where herd instinct starts to drives us towards the edge of the precipice.

“And we must ensure that the regulatory system protects both us as lenders, and our borrowers, from he risk of unscrupulous intermediation, in which the primary driver is not aligned with the customer’s interests.”


Recommended

Become an equity release referrer

I made the point last week that you should think carefully before deciding how to enter the equity release market and I hope you have taken my advice.

Debt firm takes on five more employees

TCF Debt Solutions has recruited five members of staff for its business development, debt consultant and credit control divisions.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up