View more on these topics

Brokers are worth more than this

It’s about time lenders started valuing brokers more highly for the work they do, maybe paying them an hourly rate for the time they spend on cases, says Sue Read

Last week I said that one of my new year resolutions would be to value my time more highly. I pledged to charge my clients a fair fee for the work I do for them – fair for them but also fair for me.

Then something I read made me even more determined to put this resolution into practice. Paragon Group has done some research that confirms mortgage brokers are getting record proc fees.

Apparently 95% of advisers now receive some sort of fee from lenders, with the average payment being 428 for each client. Indeed, in almost 30% of cases advisers are receiving more than 500 per case.

The immediate thought that sprang to my mind was that even at 500 per case these fees are too low. I accept that proc fees have risen over the past year but how any adviser can be making a profit solely on mortgage applications is beyond me.

I don’t know how much time it takes you to do a mortgage but consider the process – probably two client visits, a couple of hours’ research and preparation time between meetings, another couple of hours to process the application, time spent writing reports and file notes and then many phone calls to lenders, clients, solicitors and agents to bring the deal to offer and then completion.

Then there’s the administrative staff time spent inputting data, typing and chasing up outstanding information which adds several more hours (and my administrator’s a quick typist). This brings the total to more than 15 hours so the lender is basically paying you and your firm just under 30 per hour, based on the average fee. And I haven’t even factored in postage, phone and other costs which you incur on its behalf.

This means that to make mortgage work viable financially advisers must charge fees or write associated business such as life cover. Have you ever considered how much more profitable life cover or investment business is to you on an hourly basis than mortgage work?

I reckon you’ll easily be earning 100 per hour for this sort of business – even on more tricky cases – because it is much less time-consuming. Once a proposal is in, there’s little else to do.

And of course the average proc fee figure quoted is simply that – average. It will be distorted by regional house price variations and case type. For example, a buy-to-let or complex adverse case will earn more for an adviser. Therefore many cases must pay advisers well below the magic figure of 428.

So my message to lenders is this – stop trying to persuade advisers that your proc fees are generous and stop making out to clients that advisers are overpaid for their efforts. Get real. For example, start asking us to log time spent on cases and pay us a sensible hourly rate.

In short, start paying us something approaching a fair sum for our time, effort and expertise. Isn’t it about time lenders valued my time in the same way I’ve promised I will ask my clients to?


FSA fines former ING firm

The Financial Services Authority has fined a firm formally owned by ING 560,000 for widespread failings in its systems and controls resulting in poor accounting systems and inadequate client money protection. The failings at W Deb MVL occurred over a four and a half year period from December 1 2001 to May 3 2005.The primary […]

Freedom in £20m portfolio sale

Freedom Lending has completed a £20m portfolio sale to Crocus Homeloans, a subsidiary of the Saffron.

BIBA supports FSA’s PPI plans

The British Insurance Brokers’ Association has lent its support to the Financial Services Authority’s announcement that its plans to strengthen sales practices in the Payment Protection Insurance market have entered a new phase.Eric Galbraith, chief executive of BIBA, says: “It is important that consumers realise that they don’t have to take out PPI from the […]

Halifax Hispania reduces euro mortgage rates

Banco Halifax Hispania has reduced the rate on its variable euro mortgageswith immediate effect. Repayment mortgage rates of 4.633% for loans up to 60% and 4.733% for loans up to 70% of the value of the property are now available.The lender says the reduction in interest rates comes as good news for those people looking […]

Trusts: Easier than you think?

Protection providers often extol the benefits of placing plans in trust. The advantages for clients are widely recognised and numerous – inheritance tax mitigation, avoiding probate delay, controlling claim proceeds, and so the long, familiar list continues. Yet, dismissed as unnecessary form-filling, or simply viewed as irrelevant in the context of a mortgage sale, less […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up