View more on these topics

When doing good is good for business

You can’t help but feel a warm glow inside when businesses show their caring sides. Companies that you might normally consider to be profit-hungry wolves prowling the high street for consumer prey roll over on their backs like family pets, display their soft underbellies and pant as their tummies are tickled by the publicity that comes from doing good.

I’m not suggesting that their wish to help customers overcome the disadvantages they face is not genuine. But firms are so quick to squawk about their good deeds that you sometimes can’t help wondering why they set up a particular customer programme – was it to help customers or to boost sales figures?

I feel a lot more comfortable about companies’ good work when there is a degree or two of separation from their business operation. Large donations to charity with no strings attached or employees volunteering at local projects which have no obvious payback for the firms involved would be good examples.

But increasingly, companies want to align what they do for charity with the type of business they do. So when financial services companies look for suitable projects to support, or assess the ones that come asking for help, they try to find a financial tie-in that makes strategic sense.

This way of working has resulted in some excellent partnerships. Several banks help fund the free financial advice offered by Citizens Advice Bureau. Others offer support to credit unions and other organisations that help the financially excluded get access to basic banking services.

Where it starts to get murky is when companies help disadvantaged customers get access to their products. And it gets grubbier still when firms help customers get access to debt – possibly a lot of it and for a long time.

Charcol.co.uk recently announced an initiative to offer borrowers with poor credit histories the chance to get free mortgage advice tailored to their needs. The press release squawks: “In a market that is awash with brokers who charge exorbitant fees, charcol.co.uk is determined to break what it sees as the vicious circle of debt.”

According to Charcol.co.uk, annual lending in the sub-prime sector is around £30bn – about 8% of the market. And people with poor credit histories account for 70% of repossessions so there is no doubt these consumers need extra help.

But my question is – is this the help they need? Obviously, free advice is better than ripping off customers with exorbitant fees but in some cases, best advice must be that they shouldn’t have mortgages at all. Will Charcol.co.uk be telling them that or just helping itself to a slightly bigger slice of the sub-prime sector?

Recommended

Case highlights broker disclosure

The Finance Trading Standards Association is seeking legal advice following the landmark Hurstanger case. Hurstanger came under the spotlight when borrower Delroy Wilson went into arrears. Wilson claimed his original contract was void because a £240 payment from lender to broker was not disclosed. The Court of Appeal ruled that brokers must disclose commission.

BoE freezes base rate

The Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee has voted to freeze interest rates at 5.5%.This follows a 25 basis point rise in May. Although many experts predicted the MPC would hold rates over June, there have been fears that UK inflation continues to rise.This resulted in more than £25bn being wiped from the value of […]

Emoffer through DB Mortgages

em-financial has launched a free valuation and no application fee offer across DB Mortgages’ product range. It is available in England and Wales only and includes unlimited products up to 85% LTV.

Consumers seem optimistic about Blair’s departure

The Nationwide consumer confidence index rose nine points in May, reaching its highest level in 18 months.Confidence rose most sharply in the week that interest rates increased and Tony Blair announced his departure date from Downing Street.The expectations index, charting people’s sentiment about their future financial situation, rose by six points to 97 in its […]

Reforming India: just the beginning

By Kunal Desai, Neptune India Fund

As global investors continue to scour emerging markets through the lens of reform potential, India shines bright. Indeed, we think it can sparkle even brighter. We anticipate India’s self-imposed 10-year ‘policy holiday’ to turn into one of the most pro-growth and pro-investment policy calendars seen in Asia in years. The Indian electorate has engineered a historic verdict. We now have the strongest Indian government since 1984, with the pro-market Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) achieving an absolute majority for the first time in the party’s history.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up