View more on these topics

Lenders are adopting illogical criteria for retirement deals

From Helen Pierson

I am a mortgage broker and would like to highlight the illogical criteria lenders adopt in respect of lending into retirement.

I know this area looks as though it might become a hot potato for the FSA but ridiculous, unworkable criteria won’t help.

At the 11th hour Halifax asked for evidence of pension income plus a tax- free lump sum for a client aged 52 who wants a 23-year term. I called Halifax to explain my client was a prison officer with 13 years’ service remaining and was in an occupational final salary pension scheme so it was impossible to accurately project forward to provide the information required. He also intends to sell the property on retirement and downsize. All this was information already provided to Halifax.

By the silence at the other end of the line I thought I must have lapsed into Polish or that “one of the friendly members of staff” Halifax’s recorded message drones on about wasn’t available that day. Only by coaxing the recipient of my call further did I realise I might as well have been discussing splitting the atom, such was the level of their understanding of what a final salary pension scheme is.

Halifax wouldn’t budge and it was only after speaking to my area representative about the problem that I realised how ridiculous this stance is. I was flabbergasted and want to share this with as many people as possible to try and shame Halifax into doing something.

Halifax assumes the pension payable at retirement is whatever it is at current rates, regardless of the type of pension scheme and number of working years remaining before retirement. It also assumes that the mortgage is interest only even if, in the case of my client, it was submitted on a repayment basis and the debt at retirement will be the same as at inception.

In my client’s case the debt would have potentially reduced by 36,000 (taken from Halifax’s amortisation table on the KFI) by the time retirement occurred but the calculation used expected him to service the full mortgage based on a pension at today’s rates regardless of the fact that he’s got a further 13 years of service. It won’t surprise you to learn it didn’t fit.

Mortgages into retirement are a hot potato for the FSA and lenders too, which is why a common sense approach is needed. Halifax, your criteria are unrealistic and unworkable. If you won’t change them at least give your staff a basic understanding of how pensions work and why your criteria is as it is.Splitting the atom might be beyond you, but training your staff?


Paymentshield offers free home emergency and legal expenses cover

Paymentshield has added home emergency cover and legal expenses cover to its building and contents insurance products. Both additions are free to all new policy holders for the first 12 months from the policy start date. Home emergency covers the repair of damage caused to a clients home following a sudden event which makes the […]

Platform reveals Car Chaos winner

A lucky adviser has come out on top as the winner of Platforms Classic Car Chaos competition, successfully navigating their way through the online hazardous highway game.Stuart Burrows, a financial adviser at Heavenly Finances based in Manchester, cleverly planned his route around runaway sheep, dangerous drivers and flying birds to rack up a top score […]

A&L slammed for IT glitch

Alliance & Leicester has come under fire after its online system is believed to have stopped working just hours before it changed one of its product rates. Tony Rich, sole trader at Yellow Financial, says he was left having to produce a new Key Facts Illustration for his client after he could not submit the […]

BM Solutions announces Sandy Lane winner

BM Solutions has announced David Wood of Castle Mortgages, in Milton Keynes is the winner of the luxury break to Sandy Lane, Barbados. David was picked at random from all brokers who have submitted cases on the one minute mortgage application system since January.Martin Reynolds, head of sales at BM Solutions took David out to […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up