View more on these topics

Halifax underwriters should put more starch in their shirts

From Chris Stanfield

I have to agree with previous comments on these pages regarding Halifax’s poor service and its amazing invisible lending criteria.

In some cases its performance and treatment of applicants and intermediaries is appalling.

I submitted an excellent case for a 90% purchase on July 19. I supplied every document stated in the lending criteria including salary slips and P60s relating to the customer’s full-time and part-time jobs. The case was referred to a business consultant. More than three weeks later, Halifax decided to originate full employers’ references. The income more than satisfied normal multiples. Each time information or documentation was returned, Halifax took at least a week to get this onto its system and then a further 48 hours for assessment by a business consultant. This was true even for urgent faxes. Upon receipt of satisfactory references, the case was referred to a consultant who discovered that the applicant has an existing buy-to-let mortgage. Shame nobody picked this up in the application as we enclosed a copy of the mortgage statement with the application.

I was then requested to confirm that the applicant can manage both jobs and that the position is sustainable. You can see from the application that the applicant has held the second job for more than 18 months, but nevertheless I obtained this. Next was a request to supply up-to-date proof of mortgage payments (by now more than six weeks had passed) and rental income. Next we were requested to supply a copy of the assured shorthold tenancy. Then the online bank statements supplied were unacceptable (despite a logo on them) so it was off to join the long queue at the bank for duplicates. And ironically, Halifax is one of the banks most keenly encouraging customers to go paperless.

At the time of writing, a decision has yet to be made on this application – more than 10 weeks after the online application. The valuation fee was of course taken on day one.

I continue to apologise to the customer who has supplied all required items immediately upon request.

As an underwriter in a previous life, my advice to Halifax underwriters is put more starch in your shirts and don’t be afraid to say no. This would be preferable to the present system. I could have gone elsewhere more than eight weeks ago and would have a happy customer and estate agent by now. An intermediary’s reputation is easily scarred by such poor underwriting skills and dismal service.

A lender should provide a definitive list of requirements upon receipt of an application, certainly before swallowing an applicant’s valuation fee.


Public advice guide to buy-to-let published today

The Association of Residential Letting Agents and the Council of Mortgage Lenders published the annual ARLA/CML guide to buy-to-let today.It is the fourth time the guide has been published, which offers information and advice to the public on buy-to-let. It is available free through ARLA member letting agents.Topics covered in the latest guide include, expanding […]

West Brom launches buy-to-let products

West Bromwich continues to go from strength to strength in the buy-to-let sector. Lending through the intermediary channel was the highest it has been this year, and 55% of that lending was buy-to-let. The greatest increase in business has been witnessed in the West Midlands and Yorkshire and the North East, up 22% on Julys […]

I will lead push to boost ASU uptake

The small minority of brokers who moan about the concept of Treating Customers Fairly annoy me. The Arthur Daleys do not belong in our industry. But without going so far as to say there are still many Daleys around I wonder if most brokers are treating clients fairly, based on the decrease in ASU sales. […]

B&B panel shock rumoured

Bradford & Bingley will reveal its revised lending panel by the end of the year and it is rumoured there will be a shock removal, Mortgage Strategy has learned. In August MS reported the panel could be slashed from 25 lenders to eight after the high street broker’s shake-up at the start of this year […]

Pension - thumbnail

David Cameron appoints former adviser to Tony Blair as new pensions minister

Following a cabinet reshuffle in light of last week’s general election, David Cameron has announced that Ros Altmann will be replacing Steve Webb as pensions minister. As the industry works with one of the largest reforms to the sector in almost a century, the former adviser to Tony Blair has been tasked with ensuring that the pensions revolution does not stray off track.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up