View more on these topics

FCA: Lenders too cautious on straying into advice

Mortgage lenders should be less cautious about breaching the line between information and advice, the FCA says.

The regulator has today published its post-MMR thematic review into advice and distribution, which identifies a number of areas where intermediaries and lenders need to improve their practices.

The review found some lenders had adopted a cautious approach to providing information to customers, to mitigate the risks of unqualified staff providing unregulated advice. In some cases this prevented customers from accessing information about products unless they spoke to an adviser.

FCA acting director of retail lending supervision Philip Salter says: “Some firms were so cautious about not giving advice they would not answer basic questions about their product range. There really is no problem with them doing that.

“We have issued guidance on this and I think we have been clear enough. There is scope for firms to be less cautious.”

The report raised concerns about the “limited oversight and controls” in intermediary networks, while it said many lenders operate structured processes which are not flexible enough.

But Salter refused to expand on the regulator’s biggest concerns about the practices in intermediary firms and lenders specifically.

He says: “It wasn’t black and white, which is why the report did not try to portray it in that way. There was a mix of good and bad practice among different types of firms.”

Salter says the way networks are structured means effective oversight of advice is particularly challenging.

He says: “There is a challenge in the model to ensure that the range of different members all give a good, clear and consistent customer experience.

“The best practice examples we saw sat somewhere in the middle of an overly structured model and one with limited controls: one with sufficient structure to ensure all the required information was collected, but with enough flexibility for the adviser to treat each customer appropriately.”

The FCA has provided individual feedback to firms involved in the review, setting out any actions required.

But Salter says this does not include any formal supervisory actions such as past business reviews.

He says: “The aim of this piece of work is to educate, assess where we have got to and to provide information that improves standards across all firms. It was not to identify where we might need to use formal powers.

“We are only a year into the MMR and the results are never going to be perfect.”

The review found that advice was suitable in 59 per cent of cases, and unsuitable in 3 per cent of cases. The remaining 38 per cent were deemed “unclear”.

Salter says: “The ‘unclear’ cases were where the adviser had not collected all of the information that was relevant to providing advice.”



Nationwide: Housing market is still cooling

House prices dipped by 0.2 per cent in June and annual growth once again slowed as the housing market continues to cool. According to Nationwide, the average house price fell from £195,166 in May to £195,055 in June. While prices were up 3.3 per cent year-on-year, annual growth slowed for the second consecutive month from […]


NatWest Intermediary Solutions loosens buy-to-let criteria

NatWest Intermediary Solutions now considers buy-to-let applications where there a selective licencing scheme is in place where the property is situated. The lender will consider these applications provided the valuer does not highlight any issues. In areas where the local authority introduces these schemes, landlords are required to have a licence to rent out their […]

Bank of Ireland begins distributing through Intrinsic

Bank of Ireland has expanded its panel and now distributes it mortgages through Intrinsic Financial Services. The lender re-entered the broker market under its own brand in December, first distributing through LSL estate agency subsidiaries Reeds Rains, Your Move and Embrace Mortgage Services, before opening up to First Complete ARs last month. In April it began […]


Imla warns BoE not to ‘rush to judgement’ on B2L

The Intermediary Mortgage Lenders Association has warned the Bank of England not to “rush to judgement” on buy-to-let after the central bank revealed it was concerned by the sector’s rapid growth. In last week’s Financial Stability Report, the Bank warned the sector could pose a threat to the UK economy due to looser lending standards […]

Employees care about their health

It’s important employers remember this like an alarm going off in their head. Employees care about their health. And they’re calling on employers to provide them with health benefits. In a survey we conducted, we asked 1,005 UK SME employees to choose the top three employee benefits they would value most:  48% of employees voted […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up