View more on these topics

FCA chief: PI cover is not working for advisers


Professional indemnity insurance is often not working properly in the financial advice sector, FCA chief executive Andrew Bailey has acknowledged.

Speaking at the Association of British Insurers’ annual conference today, Bailey said that while advice firm failures were smaller than those of banks, PI insurers were frequently writing contracts that excluded the losses, leaving the FSCS and capital adequacy to pick up the bill.

Bailey said: “While losses as principal dominated the financial crisis – in other words, the failure of banks – and the interest costs of these failures remain even now the biggest costs being covered by the FSCS, failure of firms acting as agent are more common, if on average smaller.

“For agency firms, capital is not where we should start – as holding capital is an inefficient way of mitigating the risks posed by firms who are not typically a threat to the system. The front stop should be commercial insurance in the form of PI cover, much as it is for lawyers and other professions.

“But PI cover is not by experience always reliably performing the role, particularly in the IFA and investments world, – the contracts are framed often in ways that rule out loss absorption in the context we are dealing with here when the firm fails. What is the consequence of this? It is that the protection of client assets and ultimately the FSCS become the primary lines of defence, and this is what has happened.”

Bailey called on the insurance industry to input ideas on how to make the PI market and the FSCS work more effectively.

He said: “This is rightly a public policy issue, but it is also a private issue too because many advisory firms are meeting substantial bills for FSCS pay-outs. With all this in mind, my request today to the insurance industry is to help us to think through how we might solve this problem.”



Passing your examination the easy way

Michael Ward has spent many long and frustrating hours simplifying the CeMAP exam-taking process with the use of some cleverly composed notes he calls rapid learning guides. Before I let Ward loose on the MS platform I&#39ll tell you briefly about some people who have used Michael&#39s notes. Cameron Thurston had become disillusioned with the […]


Building society lending strong but slowing: BSA

The rate of lending growth by building societies slowed in the third quarter, according to figures from the Building Societies Association. The BSA says its members approved 110,129 new mortgage loans between July and September, up 6 per cent on the 103,758 mortgage loans approved in Q3 2015. BSA members approved 118,600 mortgages in the […]


The Mortgage Works cuts rates on 2-year loans with £1,995 fees

The Mortgage Works will cut rates on its two-year fixed and tracker rates with a £1,995 fee by up to 0.20 per cent. Rates for the lender’s existing two-year fixed rate products with a £1,995 fee have been reduced by up to 0.20 per cent and now start at 1.89 per cent. Meanwhile, TMW’s two-year […]

The return of inflation

Alex Ralph, manager of the Artemis High Income Fund, sees further pressure on government bonds as inflationary pressures build on both sides of the Atlantic.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up
  • Post a comment
  • Peter Turner 22nd November 2016 at 6:48 pm

    I have said it before and will say it again. We need PI cover that operates on the basis of today’s policy pays for liability for today’s advice, whenever a claim comes in.

    Do that and the insurer will not be able to withdraw cover when it sees a train crash about to happen and massively reduce the level of claims on the FSCS because of firms that FOS has bankrupted.