FCA asked to justify mortgage cost comparison data

The FCA has been asked to justify its mortgage cost comparison data from its recent Mortgages Market Study Interim Report.

At the FSE Manchester event today, the regulator was accused of not having taken into account the full client and market circumstances when comparing product accessibility and any potential savings consumers could have made by securing a ‘cheaper deal’.

The regulator was speaking for the first time about the study at today’s event where head of banking, lending and distribution policy Graeme McLean said it had identified that 30 per cent of mortgage borrowers could have made a significant saving on their mortgage by securing a cheaper version of the mortgage they got.

He said consumers could have saved on average £550 per year by getting a cheaper mortgage, regardless of whether that customer came through an intermediary or direct channel.

McLean suggested that because of these findings the regulator “wanted to work with the industry to help consumers to shop around”. He said the regulator had “no preference for how this would happen”.

Audience questions centred on ‘cost saving analysis’, arguing that the regulator was not able to take into account the full circumstances around why, for example, an adviser would choose not to recommend the cheapest option.

One adviser outlined that “there are a raft of reasons why we might recommend the fourth/fifth/sixth cheapest product – for example, affordability or the information provided to us”. He suggested that the regulator was effectively saying that “brokers were doing a poor job”.

Another delegate asked whether the FCA took into account a lender’s service levels or the amount of funding prescribed to a certain product in their analysis. They also suggested that the FCA seemed ‘cost fixated’ and that the industry believed this debate was “put to bed 15 years ago prior to the introduction of MCOB”. He asked whether the FCA had lost some of its “corporate memory” when it came to this issue.

The FCA’s Matthew Ward admitted that the regulator had made “a whole load of assumptions but we have tried to make conservative assumptions” with its analysis and said that in terms of service levels and other ‘soft facts’ that an adviser would take into account, “we don’t have the data”.



FCA: 25% of brokered mortgages follow estate agent suggestions

Almost a quarter of residential mortgages are taken out with advisers recommended by estate agents, according to the Financial Conduct Authority. Of those, a quarter also felt pressured to do so, the FCA adds. The FCA made the statements as part of its interim report into mortgage competition, published today. The regulator says: “Of those […]


Industry responds to FCA interim mortgage market study

  Today the FCA published its interim report into mortgage market competition, first mooted in 2015. The Financial Conduct Authority has singled out mortgage prisoners, shopping around and a broker comparison service as areas of the market that need change. The news sparked a wave of responses from the industry. UK Finance director of mortgages […]


Precise Mortgages launches new 3-year fix through Buy to Let Club

Precise Mortgages has launched an exclusive limited company buy-to-let three-year fixed rate mortgage through Buy to Let Club. The product is fixed at 3.54 per cent until 31 October 2019 up to 75 per cent LTV. It has an arrangement fee of 1.5 per cent. Early repayment charges are 3 per cent until 31 October […]

Three catalysts for European equities

By Rob Burnett, Manager of the Neptune European Opportunities Fund In recent weeks, the bear case for European equities has become more pronounced on the back of weaker-than-expected GDP data and deflation concerns. This softening in economic momentum has led some investors to question whether the ECB is behind the curve and indeed whether it […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up