View more on these topics

CML takes action on leasehold ground rent scandal


The Council of Mortgage Lenders is drawing up guidelines on tackling the unfolding ground rent scandal as it puts pressure on housebuilders over the issue, Mortgage Strategy has learned.

Last November it emerged that some property developers had been selling new-build houses on a leasehold basis with very expensive ground rents.

Some of the contracts saw ground rents double every 10 years, creating pressure on household finances and leaving homeowners with unsellable properties.

The practice garnered political criticism from communities secretary Sajid Javid and former housing minister Gavin Barwell.

Last month Nationwide brought in new lending rules on the issue. It said it would lend only on new-builds with leases of at least 125 years for flats and 250 years for houses, while ground rents had to be no more than 0.1 per cent of the property value.

Nationwide was the only lender to make an announcement on the subject.

Now the CML tells Mortgage Strategy it is drawing up guidelines for all lenders on how to handle the issue, and will publish the findings in the next few weeks.

Now the CML tells Mortgage Strategy it is drawing up information on leasehold and ground rent issues for all property professionals. It will publish the findings in the next few weeks.

CML spokesman Bernard Clarke says: “We are working on an information document setting out considerations for lenders about leasehold.

“It is also intended to be helpful for conveyancers and valuers.”

The lender trade body is also talking to the Home Builders Federation about ensuring ground rents are fair and do not cause mortgage affordability problems.

Clarke says: “Lenders have a clear regulatory requirement to take into account any significant changes to the borrower’s income and outgoings. So it is helpful to set ground rents at levels that will not materially affect affordability in the future.

“We have reinforced this with builders and with the HBF.”

HBF head of communications Steve Turner says the building trade body has been working with both lenders and the Government on the issue of fairer ground rent terms.

He says: “We have been talking to all parties about what fair terms could look like.

“I think we are progressing in terms of how that will look. We are talking to lenders about what they are comfortable with.”

Turner adds that the talks are still ongoing.

Mortgage Advice Bureau new homes director Andy Frankish says: “It’s the right approach for the two trade bodies to be working together.”

Frankish adds that brokers were blameless in the ground rent furore, but nevertheless can help ease the problem.

He says: “We feel this doesn’t fit in the part of the advice process that the broker is responsible for.  However, we have a duty of care to our customers that when we submit an application we get this factual information correct.

“That will impact on the mortgage application and what the surveyor gets when it comes through.

“We have a responsibility of awareness to be presenting the right questions when we’re submitting the mortgage application as an intermediary community.”

Many property developers that introduced the expensive ground rent clauses on new-build homes stopped using them once the issue came to light.

Taylor Wimpey has not built any leasehold properties since January this year and has set aside £130m to cover leasehold disputes.

In April, Javid said the Govern­ment would consider an outright ban as part of its response to a planned consultation on leasehold properties.

When asked by the Communities and Local Government committee if the Government would consider new laws to make sure leasehold terms were fair, Javid said: “It may be more than that…. [The Govern­ment] could ban houses built on leasehold terms for no good reason; ban it outright.”

He added: “What we are particularly focused on here is the ground rent and whether there is an unfairness in the system.”

Javid confirmed that the Gov­ernment was not targeting leaseholds on flats as part of its campaign.



Taylor Wimpey sets aside £130m for ground rent rows

Builder Taylor Wimpey has set aside £130m to cover leasehold disputes that have seen some new build homeowners pay rising yearly ground rents to freeholders. Taylor Wimpey says it started using the lease terms ten years ago in good faith, according to the Financial Times. But a wave of customer complaints have caused the firm […]


Homes and Communities Agency to rebrand as Homes England

The Homes and Communities Agency will rebrand as Homes England, according to today’s Government housing white paper. The paper, published by the Department for Communities and Local Government, says a review of the HCA found the body should still play a part in delivering homes but still needs to do more. The white paper says: […]

Mental health in the mainstream

By Amanda Docherty, senior marketing consultant Apart from career success, millions in the bank and, on appearance, coveted lifestyles, what else do Rio Ferdinand, Lady Gaga and Ellie Goulding all have in common? They’ve all demonstrated that the power of celebrity can sometimes have a more altruistic purpose than idle gossip. Recently we’ve seen respected […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up
  • Post a comment
  • Bryan Wildman 20th June 2017 at 7:23 pm

    No requirement for Leasehold. It is a cash cow for Building Companies, Freehold Managers and Solicitors. Do as you suggest Mr Javid and scrap it.

  • Chris Tranter 20th June 2017 at 10:27 am

    Can we also add to the debate the challenges around trying to buy the lease at a later date. There is no consistency in to what can be regarded as a fair price. I believe this should be built into the leasehold agreement with the ability to buy the lease at a standard price of X times the annual ground rent.

  • Carl McGovern 20th June 2017 at 10:11 am

    Personally I think new build houses being sold as leasehold should be made illegal. If all lenders take the same stand as Nationwide, or better still refuse to lend on them, the builders will simply have to stop it. There are already enough problems, with existing leasehold houses and rogue landlords, helped by sharp practice from certain law firms, causing some big problems. I am aware of a recent situation were a client was sting for over £5,000 for an unpaid ground rent bill of less than £20. From what I have learned from this particular situation, this type of thing is common place and should be stopped. Lets not add to these issues by creating yet more leasehold houses, as there is very little need to.