View more on these topics

Commercial Watch: For art and craft, we need humans

Jane Simpson TBMC 2016

Automated systems have their place but lack the creative thought and understanding needed from commercial brokers

A lot of marketing material has been produced recently espousing various sourcing and quotation systems, suggesting they are the holy grail, or at least some form of panacea, for all manner of commercial finance ills.

We have no issues with such systems and use them ourselves when appropriate. However, that is the important caveat. ‘Appropriate’ usually applies when everything related to a potential case is entirely product driven, which makes it easier for an automated system to determine ‘If this, then that’. This is much more common with buy-to-let funding.

In the world of commercial finance, things are rarely that straightforward. No system I have come across has had the ability to say: ‘If I just tweak the structure of this loan here, or apply this interpretation of the business accounts there, I believe I can get a certain lender to take a view and fund this client.’

Thankfully, automated systems have not advanced to the point where they can provide this kind of creative thought and understanding. I remain convinced, for the time being at least, that the human ability to assess information and shape it into something that, by necessity, may not entirely resemble the original is key to a commercial broker’s craft and to finding the best outcome for the borrower.

Negotiating skills
And do not get me started on whether machines can master the art of negotiating better terms with a lender. The majority of lenders are not on sourcing systems anyway because many of them do not have either products, as such, or the type of prescriptive policy or pricing criteria necessary to achieve accurate automated output.

A good example of this is a recent case where a client called to ask if we dealt with a particular lender because he had spoken to someone who had “run it through their system” and provided terms which, while not bad, were slightly short of the requested debt level.

We could deal with that lender. However, it became clear the company had extra cash resources set aside for another project, which, while available, it did not want to tie up for a long period.

An alternative lender agreed to take the surplus funds as a temporary measure to cover the slight shortfall in rent, enabling the originally requested debt amount to work within the lending policy. A full cash sweep in operation for the first year would allow the lender to release the cash held as the debt would have reduced to meet its standard policy requirements.

The borrower got not only the amount requested but at a rate over 1 per cent a year lower than the original deal presented to us.

While not every deal is like the one above, we see our fair share of cases that require quite a lot of shaping to get the client even close to what they want. Currently, no artificial intelligence is capable of this kind of thought.

And it is really so much nicer dealing with people anyway, don’t you think?

Jane Simpson is managing director at TBMC



Interest-only mortgage risk reducing, says CML

The risk of interest-only mortgages is reducing, with the number of such outstanding loans falling by a third to 1.7 million since 2012, according to the Council of Mortgage Lenders. CML research shows that there were around 3.2 million interest-only loans in 2012, when it started collecting data. The CML says the risk of this […]


Buy-to-let Watch: Change breeds innovation

The fact that buy-to-let will not be so straightforward in future may present us all with an opportunity to be creative I read an interesting article in one of the nationals last weekend. Unsurprisingly, it focused on the buy-to-let market and the tax changes introduced by George Osborne earlier this year. Little did the Chancellor […]

The seven day mortgage could prove a fraud nightmare

Will we soon be able to switch our mortgages as quickly as our bank accounts or energy deals? The Government certainly seems to think it’s a good idea. But just how realistic is this? A fortnight ago, the Department for Business, Innovation & Skills launched a consultation document on “Improving the Consumer Landscape and Quicker […]

Why your clients need some tough love

In any relationship that matters, professional or personal, you should be upfront with someone if you think they’re making a decision or doing something they might later regret. Being honest with someone and having their best interests at heart, however hard the message, is key to building trust in any relationship. So how does this […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up