View more on these topics

FCA set to close loophole in consumer buy-to-let


The City watchdog plans to close a regulatory loophole that leaves the Financial Services Compensation Scheme liable for paying claims made against brokers who advise on consumer buy-to-let.

Although the Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate this sector of the market, brokers need a supplementary permission to advise on such cases.

The FSCS normally does not cover CBTL but the FCA has realised that, if regulated mortgage brokers sell it without the correct permissions, this  could create an unexpected liability for the FSCS.

The regulator revealed this in its CP16/17 consultation paper last week.

The paper says: “CBTL activities carried out by firms that are registered under the [Mortgage Credit Directive] Order are not regulated activities under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, which means their CBTL activity is not covered by the FSCS.

“However, we have become aware that, contrary to our policy intention, some CBTL activity is potentially within the scope of the FSCS.

“This could occur if an authorised firm carries out CBTL intermediation, in breach of the order, but has not registered to do this.”

The regulator plans to change its handbook to remove all CBTL from FSCS protection, and is consulting on this. It says the move would “remove an element of consumer protection”.

The consultation paper says: “We propose amendments to the handbook to ensure that all CBTL activity is outside the scope of the FSCS.

“This includes CBTL activity carried on by an EEA firm through an establishment in the UK where the firm has chosen to top up any cover provided by a compensation scheme in its home state for its mortgage activities by obtaining cover from the FSCS.”

An FCA spokeswoman says: “In the drafting of the rulebook, it gives some CBTL customers FSCS cover when they shouldn’t have it, so we’re closing that loophole.”

The FCA and FSCS have not seen examples of brokers selling CBTL without permission, according to spokespeople. But this may have occurred without the authorities’ knowledge or the situation escalating to an FSCS claim being made.

Keystone Buy to Let Mortgages and Mortgages for Business managing director David Whittaker says lenders should check brokers’ CBTL permissions.

“If the FCA says brokers can do CBTL only if they have registered to do so, what are the lenders doing if they take an application on CBTL? They should be checking each and every one against the FCA register,” he says.

Fleet Mortgages chief executive Bob Young says his firm does not conduct CBTL but agrees that lenders should be conducting due diligence on brokers’ permissions.

He adds: “We would make sure they had the right permissions. If they were with a network, they would have the permissions. If they were an individual, we would make sure they had what they needed.”

Whittaker says the FCA should ask lenders to vet brokers more thoroughly while wait-ing for the consultation to finish.

He says: “They should say to the lenders ‘every piece of CBTL business you do, you must check, for the time being, that the broker has the relevant permissions’.”

Young says lenders will welcome the FCA move to close the loophole.

He says: “I can’t speak for the industry but my guess is lenders would always welcome clarification.

“I’m a big fan of the FCA. I know it is easily knocked by brokers and lenders but I’m a great fan and this is an example.

“If what it’s doing is saying ‘This could be a problem, let’s sort it out now’, that’s much better than waiting for it to become a problem.”


FCA logo new 3 620x430

FCA axes plans for CBTL fee but 2016/17 fees still to rise

The Financial Conduct Authority has dropped its plans to charge brokers a £200 annual flat fee for handling consumer buy-to-let, though the sector as a whole will still see a 7.1 per cent fee hike. The fee was first brought up in the FCA’s CP16/9 paper on proposed fees. The FCA says it has taken […]


Andrew Bailey begins reign as FCA chief

Former Prudential Regulation Authority head Andrew Bailey begins his new role as Financial Conduct Authority chief executive today. Bailey succeeds Tracey McDermott, who was been interim chief executive since Martin Wheatley exited in September 2015. The PRA’s most recent annual report shows Bailey was paid a total of £350,000 in 2015/16, this rises to £460,000 at the […]

FCA logo glass 2 620x430

FCA shuts down Dual Mortgage Brokers

The Financial Conduct Authority has cancelled Dual Mortgage Brokers’ permissions. The regulator said that Francis Birchall, who trades as Dual Mortgage Brokers, was not meeting its threshold conditions. Birchall had not filed a regular Retail Mediation Activities Return to the regulator, according to an FCA statement. The regulator said Wallesey-based Birchall had not run his […]

Why prevention is better than cure

Quoting the famous adage, prevention is better than cure; there are many proactive benefits that can improve wellness in the workplace, decrease stress, increase staff morale and reduce absenteeism, as well as attracting and retaining employees of a higher standard. With a recent study showing that employees in Britain are working below peak productivity, preventative benefits can ensure you address potential health issues or causes of stress at their source and ensure productivity in the workplace remains at an optimum level. With this in mind, how are you using preventative benefits to help keep your workforce happy and healthy?


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up